Comparable sales at a glance
| Property | Sold | What differs |
|---|---|---|
| 7 Hilma Street | $4.825m · 2 May 2025 · about 695.6m² advertised | Full report |
| 111 Essilia Street | Full report | Five bedrooms, downstairs guest room, several living zones and pool in a recently completed renovation. Less land, but a credible cheaper route to polished family living. |
| Full report | $5.35m · 20 Sep 2025 · about 714m² | Four bedrooms plus TV/fifth room, separate study, poolside master, large lower family/alfresco and higher specification. Shows what a premium above $5m bought locally. |
Buying this home
Our buyer-side view
Buy this for the combination of a renovated four-bedroom family home, generous covered entertaining, pool and spa, and an elevated ocean outlook in a convenient Plateau street. The price restraint is equally specific: all bedrooms are upstairs, one is notably narrow, the views look across neighbouring rooftops, and several completed sales offer more accommodation or a more ambitious architectural package for similar money.
The house behind the presentation
The current plan shows four enclosed bedrooms, all on the first floor, rather than a main house plus a flat. The master is labelled about 3.8 by 4.2 metres, with walk-in wardrobe, ensuite and access to the front covered balcony. Bedrooms three and four are approximately 3.0 by 3.5 metres and 3.6 by 3.6 metres. Bedroom two is long but only 2.4 metres wide, despite its 5.5-metre length. Test an actual bed, desk and clear circulation; floor area alone disguises the compromise.
The comparison that matters most: 7 Hilma Street
No. 7 sold for $4.825 million on 2 May 2025. Both individual major-portal sale records support that result. Its approximately 695.6m² advertised holding was only modestly larger than the subject, making this a much more useful comparison than a suburb median. It combined the same essential attractions—substantial family accommodation, pool, entertaining and ocean views—in the same street.
The cheaper challenge: 111 Essilia Street
111 Essilia sold for $4.425 million on 15 May 2026. Its selling agency, property histories and sold listings support the price. The smaller approximately 480m² block is the clearest reason it is not an equal substitute for Hilma's land and outlook. It is nevertheless a strong alternative for a buyer primarily seeking a finished family home rather than the largest block.
What paying more bought: 33 Hilma Street
No. 33 sold for $5.35 million on 20 September 2025, on approximately 714m². The price is published on Domain and supported by property histories, while its selling agency withholds the result. It is a persuasive upper comparison because the pool, outdoor kitchen, ocean outlook and renovated high-end family setting overlap with the subject's attractions.
The immediate-street challenge: 28 Hilma Street
No. 28 sold for $3.85 million on 28 September 2024, with about 677m², four bedrooms and three bathrooms. The individual sale advertising describes a newly renovated home with vaulted ceilings, open-plan living, a pool and ocean views. This is an important counterweight to the claim that a similar block and coastal renovation alone must command the present guide.
Condition, land and the street setting
What different purchase prices mean
These bands are buyer judgements before acquisition costs, assuming satisfactory title, approvals and underlying condition.
| Purchase price | Buyer judgement |
|---|---|
| Full report | Attractive. A meaningful saving against Essilia and the strongest Hilma substitute. Establish why the opportunity exists and verify the renovation rather than assuming a low price proves a bargain. |
| Full report | Reasonable. The larger land, outlook and covered entertaining can earn a premium over Essilia while retaining a useful saving against No. 7. The narrow bedroom and all-upstairs sleeping arrangement must work in practice. |
| Full report | Full. Near and above No. 7's sale price, the case depends increasingly on finish, the outdoor connection and this particular buyer's preference. There is little room to overlook workmanship, access or use-document problems. |
| Full report | Hard to justify on present evidence. The subject approaches the better equipped same-street alternatives without clearly matching their accommodation, views or architectural package. Material new evidence is needed to support more. |
Purchase approach and campaign
The current $5 million auction guide is $350,000 above our central assessment and just above the working range. Earlier material advertised $6 million; a later $1 million guide reduction is a campaign change, not evidence that a particular offer failed or that the vendor must sell. An AVM based on an old bedroom configuration and a high current AVM point in very different directions. Completed sales and the actual plan deserve greater weight than either automated number.
Living here
Shops and everyday errands
The closest useful small retail cluster is around Telopea Street and Aubreen Street, rather than the larger Veterans Parade village. Time 4 Thai confirms its address at 3/23 Telopea Street, approximately 280 metres straight-line from the home; Collaroy Plateau Cellars is at 55A Telopea Street nearby. This is useful for a takeaway or small specialist errand. It should not be confused with a full supermarket centre, and the actual walk follows streets around the school precinct.
Healthcare
Plateau Family Medicine at 52 Veterans Parade is approximately one kilometre straight-line away, close to the village shops. NSW Health's service listing and the practice's booking information identify it as a local general practice. Collaroy Medical Centre at 1030–1034 Pittwater Road offers another GP option in the coastal strip, approximately 890 metres straight-line away. Its own service page confirms management of acute and chronic conditions, vaccinations, health assessments and minor procedures. It is a different service from a hospital emergency department. Neither practice's proximity establishes appointment availability, acceptance of a new patient or a fee entitlement for every consultation.
Education
The official address-based School Finder query places 30 Hilma Street in Collaroy Plateau Public School's K–6 intake area and NBSC Cromer Campus's Years 7–12 intake area. Fresh queries on 3 November 2026 returned those schools for both 2026 and 2027. The 2027 primary result is marked future, while the secondary result is not. This is particularly useful because the public school's broader information notes intake-boundary changes; a suburb name or neighbouring property's portal label is not enough.
| School option | Practical admission context | Academic and ranking evidence |
|---|---|---|
| Collaroy Plateau Public School | Government coeducational K–6; official 2026 and 2027 address result. | Full report |
| NBSC Cromer Campus | Full report | The 2025 annual report records 22% of Year 7 students at Exceeding in numeracy and 39% of HSC results in the top two bands. SchoolRank's accessible profile supplies scores, but no dated statewide ordinal rank was verified. |
| Full report | Independent school with K–12 schooling and a Pre-Kindy program; its South Creek Road campus address is approximately 840 metres straight-line away. Application, assessment/interview, fees and an offer are separate from purchasing this house. | SchoolRank places its four 2025 HSC Top Achiever course places at #44 of 240 NSW schools on that narrow awards-count measure. |
Transport and getting around
Transport for NSW confirms route 180 between Collaroy Plateau and Warringah Mall, including stops around Hilma Street/Telopea Street, Collaroy Plateau Public School and Plateau Road at Hilma Street. It runs through the local network to Dee Why and Brookvale. The exact direction matters: return services use a different sequence around parts of the Plateau. This is a useful direct connection for shopping or onward travel, without guaranteeing a frequent service at every hour.
Outdoors and recreation
Collaroy Plateau Park, also called Vic Huxley Oval, is the most useful nearby larger recreation destination around Aubreen, Telopea and Blandford streets. Council confirms a playground, lit sportsfields, tennis court, cricket nets, picnic facilities, netball hoops and toilets, with the youth and community centre at its southern end. The Telopea approach is in the same local precinct as the shops, a several-hundred-metre neighbourhood outing rather than a drive to the beachfront. The actual entrance and facility chosen change the distance; booked sport, evening lighting and event parking also change the experience.